A letter from Beth Learn

Dear instructors and teachers.

As a mother of two and a group fitness instructor for 20 years, Beth believes any leader of any physical activity is called to be on the front lines of core health. Your words and instructions shape the bodies and minds of the people in your class, young or old.

Written for fitness instructors, PE teachers, coaches and trainers.

In this letter

  • Why Beth asks you to rethink crunches and sit ups
  • Questions teachers have asked her
  • Free resources for you
  • Six tips for training the core
  • What one PE teacher changed
Why this matters

We teach what we know until we know better.

We all strive for best practice, because we do not want to hurt the people who trust us with their bodies. It is hard to stay on top of current research on how the core really works, with all its muscular layers.

Beth believes crunches and sit ups can do more harm than good, especially with incorrect technique. She sees poor alignment, abdominal separation, incontinence and chronic low back pain at high levels in the people who write to her, and she asks every instructor to look at how we train the core. Read more about crunches (log in).

Watch Beth’s short message to teachers.

A message to instructors and teachers
Teachers write to Beth

You asked. Here is where to start.

Parents hand out our free letter to PE teachers, and many of you wrote back to Beth with questions like these.

“I was only taught to teach crunches and sit ups! How do I teach without them? Do I just have my students do planks?”

A teacher

“What about the Presidential Physical Fitness Test? If we don’t do situps, how will my students be ready for it?”

A teacher

“One of my clients in my step aerobics class gave me your letter and said she can’t do the abs workout I teach at the end of class, and I have no idea what modifications to provide. I thought only pregnant women have this? Help!”

A group fitness instructor

“After reading the letter a mom gave me, I panicked! Where can I find more info? I think I have this ab separation! And what’s worse, I think several of my students have this, and I hope I haven’t made it worse!”

A teacher
Six tips

Thinking outside the six-pack.

First, two points. The six-pack is the poster child for our abdominals, but it is not the biggest or strongest of our core muscles, and its main job is stabilizing and protecting the spine, not crunching. Second, your clients and students spend most of their waking and sleeping lives in a crunched, fetal position, so they do not need more motion in that direction. Beth encourages motion in the opposite direction: upright, elongated, joints stacked.

Tip 1Move away from crunch-like motionsAny movement that encourages repetitive, careless flexing of the spine is undesirable when people already spend so much time curled forward. In Beth’s opinion, based on years of research and case studies, crunches and sit ups are often detrimental to a healing core. They hunch the spine and target just two muscles, the psoas and the rectus abs, which in most people need more balancing and stretching, not more flexing. There are better ways to target the six-pack and hit other muscles at the same time. Crunches should not be the main mode of core training.
Tip 2Think verticalThe abdominal muscles exist to support and protect the spine in an upright position. We want the range of motion, but we do not want to be stuck in crunched and twisted postures. Beth is not saying to stand and brace or twist. She is saying to walk, work in the garden, pick apples, lift heavy things, carry children and groceries, play toss and catch, wash the windows. Your abs are active in all of those.
Tip 3Think balanceMany think twisting is needed to recruit the obliques, but their job is more importantly to prevent twisting. Staggered stances, with one foot behind or off to one side, recruit the obliques and deep core with no twisting. Try throwing while standing on one foot, Tree Pose and Warrior Poses from yoga, a squat with the heels on the ground, or bending to pick something up on one foot with the hips level. (That last move is not suited to a woman in her last trimester or someone with an existing diastasis, because of gravity’s pull on the abs.)
Tip 4Think sidewaysFace-down moves and spinal flexion are rough on a healing core, and they create a lot of intra-abdominal pressure in people who cannot keep good alignment and transverse abdominis activation. Once a diastasis or other ab injury has healed, and you can keep your transverse engaged and maintain a neutral spine and pelvis, you can befriend planks again. Meanwhile, why not side planks or side bridges, the Side-Leg Series from Pilates, or cartwheels? A cartwheel is just a rotating plank that starts upright.
Tip 5Think alignmentPass out measuring tapes and have participants measure their bellies slumped versus sitting up straight. Play with plumb lines or weighted string to see whether ears, shoulders, mid ribs, hips, knees and ankles line up. Act out emotions to connect mood with posture. Balance books on heads while walking. These are ways to connect your students with their core in everyday ways they will not soon forget.
Tip 6Think playgroundHanging and swinging from bars works the whole upper torso. Beth finds that hanging from monkey bars helps redirect rounded shoulders and fires up the whole core cylinder. We are meant to climb, reach tall shelves and manage ladders. Have kids watch each other’s cores while they swing, and put that pull-up bar to use. Katy Bowman has an interesting article on hanging and swinging.

These are Beth’s views from years of working with clients. They are not medical advice.

A teacher’s story

What one PE teacher changed.

Lori is a high school health and PE teacher. She introduced herself in our member forum, then wrote Beth a summary of the changes she made, and gave permission to share it.

“My mind is blown about abdominals!! Much of what I was taught and have been teaching is wrong!! I can’t wait to get back to school to share what I’ve learned with my students. I’m now a reformed ab shredding, planking, crunch-aholic.”

Lori N., high school health and PE teacher

1. A new warm-up

She never liked the classic static stretching. Her basic warm-up is now: belly breaths x 3; a belly breath with a 5-count transverse abdominis (TA) hold, or 5 TA pulses; an oblique exercise (a TA hold side to side, or sliders); and a modified sun salutation series. She plans to add new moves through the year.

2. A different fitness test

Her school uses a fitness test that requires curl-ups. She used a one-minute TA pulsing session instead. Students counted how many they could do, stopping when they were tired or could not keep good form. They averaged 22 in the minute.

3. Core cues in everything

She reminds students to be aware of their abs during activities, for example exhaling during the twisting motion of a football throw to draw the abs in, and checking posture and alignment, sitting on the sits bones rather than the tailbone.

4. Talking with colleagues

It did not take much convincing. She shared what she had learned at before-school in-services, and her co-workers were receptive.

Share your journey

Bring your fellow teachers along.

Not in a “you need to do what I’m doing” way, but with love and commiseration. Something like, “Hey, you’d never believe what I’ve been learning! Have you heard about diastasis recti? I think some of our students might have it… I’m learning some new moves, too!”

People want to get better. They want healthy tummies. All they need is the right information and some encouragement. You are positioned to do just that, and you have Beth’s blessings and support. — Beth

Fit2B and Beth Learn can’t provide medical advice. This page is for general information and does not replace an in-person assessment. Please check with a healthcare provider about what is right for a particular body.

Learn the moves, then share them.

Start with a free account: six Tummy Smart workouts and our community. We have 300+ Tummy Smart workouts in all.

No card needed to start. Cancel any paid plan any time.